Discussion about this post

User's avatar
RICARDO's avatar

Hey David,

Your essay paints a dire and richly detailed portrait of our political moment. something between Shakespearean tragedy and political horror-comedy, with a generous helping of gallows humor. But as dark as the canvas is, I’d like to respond with a message of hope, and yes, maybe a dash of defiant optimism, even if it means laughing through our collective tears.

History, as you rightly note, is full of cases where the bad guys fought harder, shouted louder, and steamrolled the timid. But history also reminds us that resistance doesn’t always roar from the front lines. sometimes, it simmers in school board elections, bubbles up through grassroots organizing, and eventually bursts through in moments no one saw coming, womans suffrage, civil rights,gay rights fighting for a voice during the aids crisis... Remember, in 2020, a broad and diverse coalition of Americans; suburban moms, first-time voters, college students in pajama pants with Dorito dust on their fingers helped eject a sitting president for the first time in decades. That's no small feat. If democracy is dying, it’s doing so very slowly, with thousands of people filing lawsuits, knocking doors, and fact checking facebook posts with the persistence of caffeinated librarians. And though we may not have the theatrics of a revolution, I’d argue that boring resistance is a superpower. Civic institutions, bureaucracies, and journalists not exactly the Avengers, I know are often the ones who keep the wheels of democracy grinding forward, one FOIA request at a time. The Trumpian chaos machine thrives on spectacle; it withers under subpoenas, spreadsheets, and steady governance. Also, never underestimate humor as resistance. From Alec Baldwin’s impersonations to Twitter threads full of memes roasting Trump’s vocabulary (“unpresidented,” anyone?), satire has become the left's unofficial therapy and weapon. Even fascists can't survive ridicule forever... it turns out that while fear makes followers, laughter builds solidarity.

So yes, the Trumpian mob is loud. Yes, the system feels rickety and rigged. But amid the noise, there’s a growing generation that’s more diverse, more plugged in, and more allergic to authoritarianism than any before. Gen Z may not always spell check their protest signs, but they sure as hell know how to get 3 million views for dunking on a corrupt politician with a TikTok dance.

We’re still here. Still voting. Still arguing. Still dreaming. And as long as we can laugh, mobilize, and keep talking about what kind of world we want — even if we do it with exasperated sighs and sarcastic hashtags there’s still hope. I believe in America. In short: The resistance may not be loud, but it’s stubborn. Like your weird uncle at Thanksgiving who won’t leave, democracy keeps showing up, even if everyone thought it had already called it a night.

Keep writing, keep fighting, and keep laughing.

With determined hope (and a side of snark)

Expand full comment

No posts